File A Claim
Aeigis General Insurance Agency
4507 N Front Street
Suite 200
Harrisburg, PA 17110-1787
Website
Customer Service: 1-800-662-5752
Online Payment Link
Claims: 800-233-2160
Agency Insurance Company (AIC)
PO Box 8900
Elkridge, MD 21075
Website
Customer Service: 800-492-5629
Online Payment Link
Claims: 800.841.5241
Allegany Co-Op
9 North Branch Rd.
Cuba, NY 14727
Website
Customer Service: tel
Online Payment Link
Online Claim Link
Allstate Insurance
PO Box 660598
Dallas, TX 75266-0598
Website
Customer Service: 877-810-2920
Online Payment Link
Online Claims Link
American Modern Insurance
PO Box 5323
Cincinnati, OH 45201
Website
Customer Service: 800-543-2644
Online Payment Link
Online Claim Link or call: 800-375-2075
Amtrust
800 Superior Avenue E.
21st Floor
Cleveland, OH 44114
Website
Customer Service: 1-877-528-7878
Online Payment Link
Online Claim Link
Auto Owners
6101 Anacapri Blvd.
Lansing, MI 48917
Website
Customer Service: 1-800-346-034
Contact Info
Online Payment Link
Online Claim Link
Central Co-Operative Insurance Company
6 Southgate Rd
Baldwinsville, NY 13027
Website
Customer Service: 315-635-7606
Contact Info
Online Payment Link
Online Claim Link
Cincinnati Insurance Company
PO Box 145496
Cinncinnati, OH 45250-5496
Website
Customer Service: 1-888-242-0888
Online Payment Link
Claims: 1-877-242-2544
Dryden Mutual
12 Ellis Drive
P.O. Box 635
Dryden, NY 13053
Website
Customer Service: 800-724-0560
Contact Information
Online Payment Link
Online Claim Link
Employers
PO Box 32036
Lakeland, FL 33802-2036
Website
Customer Service: 1-888-682-6671
Online Payment Link
Online Claim Link
Erie & Niagra Insurance Association
PO Box 9062
Williamsville, NY 14231
Website
Customer Service: 1-716-632-5433
Online Payment Link
Online Claim Link
Farmers & Mechanics Mutual
PO Box 900
Lititz, PA 17543
Website
Customer Service: 1-800-375-3252
Online Payment Link
Claims: 1-855-725-5642
Foremost Insurance Group
PO Box 0915
Carol Stream, IL 60132
Website
Customer Service: 1-888-888-0080
Online Payment Link
Online Claims Link
Claims (personal): 1-800-527-3907
Claims (auto): 1-800-274-7865
Claims (business): 1-800-435-7764
Grundy Insurance
400 Horsham Rd.
Horsham, PA 19044
Website
Customer Service: 1-800-338-4006
Online Payment Link
Online Claims Forms
Hagerty
PO Box 1303
Traverse City, MI 49685-1303
Website
Customer Service: 1-877-922-9701
Online Payment Link
Online Claim Form
Hanover Insurance Group
PO Box 580045
Charlotte, NC 28258
Website
Customer Service: 1-800-922-8427
Online Payment Link or 1-800-573-1187
Online Claims Link: 1-800-628-0250
Lititz Mutual Insurance Company
PO Box 900
2 North Broad Street
Lititz, PA 17543-7007
Website
Customer Service: 1-800-626-4751
Online Payment Link
Claims: 1-855-725-5642
Livingston Mutual Insurance Company
PO Box 900
2 North Broad Street
Lititz, PA 17543-7007
Website
Customer Service: 1-800-724-0074
Online Payment Link
Claims: 855-725-5642
Main Street America Group
220 Salina Meadows
Suite 200
Syracuse, NY 13212
Website
Customer Service: 1-800-962-5515
Online Payment Link
Claims: 1-877-425-2467
Merchants Insurance Group
250 Main Street
Buffalo, NY 14202
Website
Customer Service: 800-462-1077
Online Payment Link
Online Claim Link
Millville Mutual
215 S. State Street
Millville, PA 17846
Website
Customer Service: 1-800-262-8495
Online Payment Link
Online Claim Link
MMG
44 Maysville Road
Presque Isle, ME 04769-3220
Website
Customer Service: or 1-888-664-2455
Online Payment Link
Online Claim Link
Natural Catastrophe (Cat Coverage)
3785 South 700 East
Second Floor
Salt Lake City,UT 84106
Website
Claims: 801-316-4228
Online Payment Link
New York Central Mutual (NYCM)
3815 California Rd.
Orchard Park, NY 14127
Website
Customer Service: 1-800-234-6926
Online Payment Link
Claims: 1-800-234-6926
Plymouth Rock
PO Box 55933
Boston, MA 02205-5933
Website
Customer Service
Online Payment Link
Online Claims
Progressive Insurance
6300 Wilson Mills Rd.
Mayfield Village, OH 44143
Website
Customer Service: 1-800-776-4737
Online Payment Link
Online Claim Link
Security Mutual Insurance Company
PO Box 4620
Ithaca, NY 14852-4620
Website
Customer Service: 1-607-257-500
Online Payment Link
Selective Insurance Company of America
PO Box 782747
401 Market Street
Philadephia, PA 19106
Website
Customer Service: 1-800-735-3284
Online Payment Link or call: 1-888-974-7400
Online Claims Link or call: 1-866-455-9969
Payments (regular)
Selective
Box 371468
Pittsburgh, PA 15250-7468
Payments (overnight)
Selective
500 Ross St.
Room 154-0470
Pittsburgh, PA 15262
ATTN: Box 371468
The Hartford
The Hartford
690 Asylum Avenue
Hartford, CT 06155
Website
Customer Service: 1-860-547-5000
Online Payment Link (personal)
Online Payment Link (business)
Online Claim Link
Travelers Insurance
Online Payment Link
Online Claims Link
Personal Insurance Payments
PO Box 660307
Dallas, TX 5266-0307
Website
Customer Service: 1-800-842-5075
Claims: 1-800-252-4633
Business Insurance Online Payments
Customer Service: 1-800-252-2268
Claims: 1-800-238-6225
Business Insurance Payments
Travelers CL Remittance Center
PO Box 660317
Dallas, TX 75266-0317
Universal Property and Casualty
1110 W.Commercial Blvd
Suite 300
Fort Lauderdale, FL 33309
Website
Customer Service: 1-800-425-9113
Online Payment Link
Online Claims Link or call: 1-800-470-0599
Utica National Insurance Group
PO Box 530
Utica, NY 13503-0530
Website
Customer Service: 1-866-860-1914
Online Payment Link
Online Claims Link
Speak With An Expert
Tell us what product line you're interested in and an expert who is best suited to your needs will be in touch within the next business day.
